Bat-Bot vs Baddies - Detective Comics vol 8 Blood of Heroes (2015)

 

Front cover of Detective Comics vol 8
Front cover of Detective Comics vol 8

This book collects the following comics: Detective Comics (New 52) #41-47 
 
Buy on Amazon
 

Score (out of 5 Capes)


1 out of 5 Capes for a series of stories that are not Batman, not Detective and not interesting.

My Review

A decade after it ended and was replaced by Rebirth, the New 52 era of DC Comics remains a deeply disliked period of DC Comics history. The discussion boards and sub-reddits are filled with people expressing their strong and usually negative assessments of the era.

To me, it is a mixed bag. The era brought us so many titles focused on minor or desperately underserved characters, such as Firestorm, Katana, Blue Beetle, Hawk & Dove and more. It was a huge positive from a line that is too often focused on its holy trinity of Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman. But these series tended to be short-lived, while longer-running titles followed a common pattern: exciting new treatments sliding into ever-darker storylines until they hit rock-bottom.

Like Superman: such a brilliant reboot in its earliest volumes but the latter stages of the New 52 era brought us the truly awful Truth storyline. Or the Earth-2 series, which were fresh and delightful in the early issues but wound up in a hole that successive creative teams could not escape.

Volume 8 of the New 52-era Detective Comics series has landed ungracefully into just such a hole.

The book opens with the barest of orientations to a radically different Gotham context. The true Batman has disappeared and, in his place, James Gordon has shaved his head into a Mohawk hairdo and put on a bat-themed mecha-style battle-suit.

It is a radically different context from the previous collection, or if you were reading the floppy comics on a monthly basis, then even from last issue. So radical that it begs for some scene-setting, a brief "Previously.." section or even an old-style editor's note. But nothing explains how we got from regular-Batman to Police-backed mecha-Batman.

James Gordon now wears the suit, aided by a large but limited support team, some members of the police force and others on the tech side, to keep fixing or modifying the suit. Harvey Bullock, his partner Nancy Yip and former partner Renee Montoya lead the charge from the police side. Their partnerships, both past and present, are a highlight of the story arc as they struggle with trust and betrayal.

The extended opening story sees a team of well-equipped, athletic and intelligent mercenaries pull off a series of crimes, including some traps for Batman, all leading up to a planned assassination attempt. A mafia crime family fits in. A giant robot Joker, less so.

A two-part appearance with the Justice League follows, and does fill in some of the gaps about what has happened to the Bruce Wayne Batman. Once they satisfy themselves that he is truly unable to play the crime-fighter any more, they adopt Gordon and the suit for a mystery with a giant alien skeleton. It devolves, unfortunately, into a tragi-comic farce, the glimmers of sweet melancholy dwarfed by the goofiness.

Peter Tomasi has written some strong Batman stories elsewhere. These are not his finest work, limited in part by the evolution away from Wayne and toward Gordon in the larger Batman environment.

Artists Fernando Blanco andMarcio Takara give us some great close-ups and visual character profiles, especially Blanco's work with the multi-racial partners in the opening tale. The Gotham world is dark and foreboding, the tech-heavy bat-suit often overly dark and visually hard to read.

There have been better Detective Comics stories, even in the New 52 era.

What I loved

Nancy Yip, Bullock's dirty-cop girlfriend
Bullock's dirty-cop girlfriend

The one highlight I found in these pages is the love interest for Gotham Police officer Harvey Bullock. The grouchy, dishevelled cop not only is playing a key role in Gordon's little Batman escapades, but he has fallen in love with Nancy Yip, his Asian-American partner. Unfortunately, she may be yet another dirty cop, in the pocket of the local mobster family.

Striking, weell-drawn Asian-American Cop
Striking Asian-American Cop

Yip shows a strength of character throughout her brief time in these stories, and I love the work of Fernando Blanco who pulls out her Asian features in sometimes explicit, other times subtle and often strikingly beautiful ways. I see why Bullock is so smitten.

What I didn't love

Bat-bot vs Joker-bot
Bat-bot vs Joker-bot

The whole battle-suit Batman is ridiculous enough. But once the giant Joker-bot starts rampaging across the page and through the city, it reaches new depths.

While their confrontation sounds dramatic, and their size and firepower should frighten the poor citizens in their path, it amounts to little more than a blip in the story, a sideshow distraction from the real story of dirty cops unfolding under a circus tent.


Silly baby monster captures Justice Leaguers
Silly JL Guest Story

On the heels of the first story arc comes a two-parter with the Justice League making a guest appearance. It finally fills in some of the details of the regular Batman's disappearance - Bruce Wayne has such deep amnesia that even Wonder Woman's lasso of truth can find no trace of the hero they knew.

Nothing else is worth revisiting in these pages. They desperately need Bruce for his detective mind, but settle for Jim Gordon in his Bat-robot armour instead. He makes a couple lame observations, leading the team to get captured by a giant alien infant in search of its now-dead mother. What started out with some horrific, literally eye-popping imagery devolves into a tragic sci-fi yarn. Yawn.

Related Reviews

Detective Comics vol 5: Gothtopia

Detective Comics vol 7: Anarky

Batman / Superman: Before Truth sees Robo-Batman and the Superman Truth story collide. Ouch!

Quick Reference Details

Writers:  Peter J. Tomasi 
Artists:  
Fernando Blanco, Marcio Takara
Published By:  DC Comics
Published When:  Aug 2, 2016
Parental Rating: Teen


Back cover of Detective Comics vol 8
Back cover of Detective Comics vol 8

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Peeping Val - Brian K. Vaughan's Spectators (2025)

Announcing a New, Mobile-friendly Look!

Missing the target - Elektra: Révérence (2014)